Gene therapy for a form of β-thalassaemia, a genetic disorder whose sufferers require frequent blood transfusions because they cannot properly produce red blood cells, seems to have been successful in a patient who, three years after treatment, no longer requires transfusions1. Doubts remain, however, over whether a set of lucky circumstances is behind the success.
Patients with β-thalassaemia carry faulty copies of the genes needed to produce the β-globin chain of haemoglobin, sometimes lacking the genes altogether. This leads to a shortage of red blood cells, the body's oxygen carriers.
Sufferers must have regular blood transfusions throughout their lives, an inconvenient and debilitating regime that ultimately shortens life expectancy. The only known cure is stem-cell transplantation, but few patients are able to find a suitable donor.
Because of the gruelling nature of this treatment, the development of gene therapies for β-thalassaemia is seen by many as an exciting prospect. The subject of the latest trial was an 18-year-old man with βE/β0-thalassaemia — in this form of the disease, one copy of the β–globin gene produces unstable β-globin and the other copy is non-functional.
Around half of the patients with this form of β-thalassaemia are dependent on transfusions, and the patient concerned had received blood transfusions since the age of three.
Philippe Leboulch of Harvard Medical School, part of the team that carried out the study, described the treatment as "life-changing". "Before this treatment, the patient had to be transfused every month. Now he has a full-time job as a cook," he says.
However, Michael Antoniou of King's College London, suggests that this case was "an extremely fortuitous event", and that the positive outcome seen is unlikely to be repeatable in other patients.
The procedure was carried out as follows. In 2007, an international team led by Marina Cavazzana-Calvo of University Paris-Descartes extracted haematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) from the patient's bone marrow. These cells give rise to all blood cell types, including the haemoglobin-containing red cells. The researchers cultured these cells, and mixed them with vectors based on the lentiviruses — a retrovirus subgroup with a long incubation period — into which a functional copy of the β-globin gene had been introduced. These vectors were shown in preclinical trials to be safer than those derived from the retroviruses — which are also replicated in a host cell — that have been used in previous gene-therapy procedures.
Chemotherapy was used to eliminate as many of the patient's faulty HSCs as possible, to prevent dilution of the genetically corrected cells, which were then transplanted. Levels of healthy red blood cells and normal β-globin in the subject's body gradually rose until, around a year after the treatment, he no longer required transfusions. After 33 months he remains mildly anaemic, but the fact that he remains transfusion-free has been hailed as a success.
However, that achievement is tempered by a cautionary note. The researchers have detected overexpression of a protein called HMGA2, which has been linked to cancers, in a high proportion of the genetically modified cells.
Overexpression occurred because the lentivirus vector can randomly integrate into chromosomes. By chance, one transplanted haematopoietic cell clone contains a vector insertion in the HMGA2 gene. A year after the transplant, the researchers noticed that the proportion of genetically modified cells that originated from this particular cell clone was rising until it reached a plateau at around 50%.
The reasons for the over-representation of that particular clone remain unclear, but that could be down to the fact that the patient's haematopoietic system was reconstituted from just a few modified HSCs. Luigi Naldini, a gene-therapy researcher at San Raffaele Telethon Institute for Gene Therapy in Milan, Italy, says that successfully grafting a larger initial population of modified HSCs could potentially prevent the problem from developing.
Looking at the haematopoietic system in its entirety, the researchers found that increased levels of HMGA2 were present in only about 5% of the patient's circulating cells, but overexpression of HMGA2 has led to enlargement of the patient's red blood cells. The researchers say that this enlargement caused by the overexpression of HMGA2 could be partly responsible for the therapeutic benefits, but it could also be a signal of future malignancies.
Antoniou suggests that the HMGA2 effect is "key" to the therapeutic effect, and that without the unintended insertion, combined with the patient's ability to produce some β-globin naturally, transfusions would probably still be required.
But Leboulch says that β-globin production from the modified cells was just as high before the cells containing the insertion reached the 50% mark, so that most of the therapeutic effect must be due to the implanted modified cells, rather than the expansion of the blood cells caused by the HMGA2 insertion. And Naldini says that the fact that β-globin expression by the implanted cells is being seen at all represents a major step forward.
A defective haemoglobin gene has been successfully replaced with a healthy copy.
The genetic disorder β-thalassaemia demands blood transfusions throughout life.Andrey Prokhorov/iStockphoto
Copyright: Cavazzana-Calvo, M. et al. Nature 467, 318-322 (2010).